+- Computer Graphics Bulletin Board (https://cg-bb.com)
+-- Forum: 3d animation and design forums (https://cg-bb.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Autodesk Softimage Forum (https://cg-bb.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=19)
+--- Thread: Whats the difference between cinema4d and softimage? (/showthread.php?tid=106)
Whats the difference between cinema4d and softimage? - MaryBrennan - 01-22-2011
Whats the difference between cinema4d and softimage?
Re: Whats the difference between cinema4d and softimage? - JerryTeague - 01-22-2011
in theory very little. both can do the same job in different way. c4d is easier to learn. Sofimage xsi has the same toolset as c4d, as do all 3d packages with additonal features built for gaming and filming industry. xsi has a addition called ICE, the interactive creative environment, and some really complex tools for manipulation high density models. both can use node based scripting to help build complex interactive 3d scenes. if you're starting out try cinema to understand its limitations then try xsi and spend a long time in its huge 3d arena.
Re: Whats the difference between cinema4d and softimage? - GuadalupeEsters - 01-22-2011
I am not sure if you have any experience with 3D applications so I am going to assume that you are a beginner.
Both Softimage and Cinema 4D will allow you to model, texture, animate, and render out of the box. In other words, both applications will provide you with a lot of the same functionality.
Here are the biggest differences to me:
1. There is a free version of Softimage available called Softimage ModTool. This has much of the same functionality of the full version of Softimage 7. 5. I believe there are rendering limitations and export limitations; however, it will export to . FBX or Collada with some available add-ons. You can read about Softimage ModTool here:
hxxp: usa. autodesk. com / adsk / servlet / pc / item?id=13571257&siteID=123112
2. Cinema4D has a Core version that you can purchase for $995 that will allow you to get into the commercial software for much cheaper than you can with Softimage. However, as you might guess by the name, there is a lot of important functionality that is missing from this version.
3. To get all of the same professional-level features in Cinema4D that you get in Softimage you will have to spend about $700 more for the Cinema4D Studio bundle. All of the functionality that you get from Cinema 4D's add-on modules is already present inside the Softimage commercial edition.
4. There is a ton of available training for Softimage and quite a bit of it is free.
5. Cinema4D does include the awesome BodyPaint3D plugin which allows you to texture a 3D model with in a full 3D viewport with texture painting tools. You can also paint textures inside Softimage but its tools for this are very limited. I personally use a different application for this called 3D Coat that is low-cost, very easy to use, and professional. Other alternatives for this would include ZBrush and Mudbox.